You are not logged in. Please login at www.codechef.com to post your questions!

×

How fair is the Top Contributors list?

12
2

Codechef discuss forum is a very nice community. I have also answered some basic questions on it. But, since past few days I see some people deliberately upvoting all the old answers of their friends so that their friends can go up in top contributors list. It seems like people are more concerned about convincing their friends to upvote their answers than really helping people and learning through the community.

This is not the first time such thing happened, take a look at this thread. This is really frustrating now. Here are the observations since yesterday.

@haresh_kh got more than 20 upvotes : 4 from @adkroxx, 3 from @hm_98, 4 from @deva2802, 3 from @sahil_g, 3 from @tirth14, 2 from @ketanhwr, 1 from @aka38

@hm_98 got more than 19 upvotes : 6 from @adkroxx, 6 from @deva2802, 3 from @haresh_kh, 3 from @sahil_g, 1 from @aka38

@sahil_g got more than 19 upvotes : 5 from @adkroxx, 4 from @aka38, 5 from @hm_98, 5 from @haresh_kh

The most intresting part is they are all from IIT Roorkee. This observation is only since yesterday not full month. Is this fair?

asked 31 Mar '16, 16:06

ash_code's gravatar image

3★ash_code
475114
accept rate: 15%

edited 31 Mar '16, 17:29


Hey ash_code, We will investigate all these accounts in question, and if we find anything fishy we will take necessary action against all the accounts involved.Thanks for reporting it to us.

link

answered 31 Mar '16, 17:44

admin's gravatar image

0★admin ♦♦
19.8k350498541
accept rate: 36%

Hey All, we will look into all these cases and will take necessary action. However, we would strongly recommend to report any such instances through email with some concrete evidence, rather than posting them on the forum it will help us look into the issue in a better way.

link

answered 24 Nov '16, 14:53

admin's gravatar image

0★admin ♦♦
19.8k350498541
accept rate: 36%

@mathecodician few days ago I informed admin about this issue and they said they will look into this matter, but they haven't done anything yet, although you can mail them at feedback@codechef.com.
user @an2609 has got total 18 upvotes from @vinay_goel21, @prrateekk, and @ishan_nitj and 10 upvotes from @kapoor_rakshit and all of them are from same college.

link

answered 24 Nov '16, 13:58

srd091's gravatar image

5★srd091
1.6k111
accept rate: 42%

edited 24 Nov '16, 14:06

2

I mailed them. Thanks for taking some action.

(24 Nov '16, 14:07) mathecodician6★

Thanks for the email id.

(24 Nov '16, 14:08) mathecodician6★

That's basically 280 free karma points.

(24 Nov '16, 14:08) mathecodician6★
2

exactly, lets hope @admin will resolve the issue soon.

(24 Nov '16, 14:10) srd0915★

This is happening again now.
@pkien got more than 20 upvotes from @nit01.
@anshal21 got about 10 upvotes from @anmol137dh08 and also about 7 from @saksham2405.
This is not fair. They are all getting upvotes from their friends.

2 or 3 upvotes is fine as their friends sometimes need laddus to ask questions but these people are getting upvotes for coming in the top contributors list.

link

answered 24 Nov '16, 13:19

mathecodician's gravatar image

6★mathecodician
2.6k1932
accept rate: 7%

Some of the users who upvoted have not solved even 1 problem on codechef. They might be the same person.

(24 Nov '16, 13:21) mathecodician6★

Also all these upvotes are within like 15 minutes so it's not a coincidence.

(24 Nov '16, 13:23) mathecodician6★

@admin please see.

(24 Nov '16, 13:25) mathecodician6★
2

It turns out that @pkien only upvoted @nit01 answers for him to upvote @pkien.

(24 Nov '16, 13:28) mathecodician6★
4

also @an2609 got more than 10 upvotes from @kapoor_rakshit and @vinay_goel21 all are from same university. @admin please look

(24 Nov '16, 13:42) diveshuttam4★

Do you know the e-mail id of codechef discuss so I can mail them.

(24 Nov '16, 13:49) mathecodician6★

They get 20 upvotes answering 10 questions whereas I have answered more than 50 questions for coming in the top contributor list. All the hardwork goes waste like this.

(24 Nov '16, 13:55) mathecodician6★

exactly same feeling here

(24 Nov '16, 14:08) diveshuttam4★
2

and @nit01 have registered on codechef just an hour ago and have upvoted 24 times.

(24 Nov '16, 14:18) srd0915★
4

I think @pkien and @nit01 are/is the same person.

(24 Nov '16, 14:21) mathecodician6★

@anshal21, @anmol137dh08 and @saksham2405 are from the same college.

(24 Nov '16, 14:25) mathecodician6★
showing 5 of 11 show all

Again now @arpit728 'the top contributor of last month' was voted a lot by @saksham458. About 5-6 times in one minute. It is again happening now.

link

answered 01 Jan '17, 00:56

mathecodician's gravatar image

6★mathecodician
2.6k1932
accept rate: 7%

@admin please see

(01 Jan '17, 10:21) mathecodician6★

I have also seen this many times. And guess what if I downvote a answer which I feel is not upto the mark then that person downvotes me back for no reason. People get a life!

link

answered 31 Mar '16, 18:28

dushsingh1995's gravatar image

4★dushsingh1995
92313
accept rate: 11%

This is very unfair.

(31 Mar '16, 18:39) ash_code3★

Ok now I have found another fishy activity. This user @sarvagya3943 got most of his upvotes from @alan_123456 who hasn't solved any problem on Codechef but has karma 71. It seems that he has only registered himself to upvote @sarvagya3943 answers. The minimum karma to upvote was also provided to @alan_123456 by @sarvagya3943. I think they are both the same person having two accounts. It is against the Codechef Code of Conduct. Just look at their karma activity and you will know what is happening.

link

answered 31 Mar '16, 18:32

ash_code's gravatar image

3★ash_code
475114
accept rate: 15%

edited 31 Mar '16, 20:42

How do you know who upvoted whom?

link

answered 31 Mar '16, 18:53

likecs's gravatar image

6★likecs
3.7k2380
accept rate: 9%

Open Codechef Discussion profile then see 'karma history'.

(31 Mar '16, 20:03) dushsingh19954★

Yes. Just open 'karma history' and you will know.

(31 Mar '16, 20:40) ash_code3★

@ash_code If the admin has said they will look into the matter, leave it to them. Why is everybody going on doing their own investigation and taking names? It is not correct to take names on a public platform. Grow Up.

link

answered 01 Jan '17, 14:34

adityaghosh996's gravatar image

6★adityaghosh996
1055
accept rate: 0%

@admin says but mostly they forget about it.

(01 Jan '17, 14:47) mathecodician6★
toggle preview
Preview

Follow this question

By Email:

Once you sign in you will be able to subscribe for any updates here

By RSS:

Answers

Answers and Comments

Markdown Basics

  • *italic* or _italic_
  • **bold** or __bold__
  • link:[text](http://url.com/ "title")
  • image?![alt text](/path/img.jpg "title")
  • numbered list: 1. Foo 2. Bar
  • to add a line break simply add two spaces to where you would like the new line to be.
  • basic HTML tags are also supported
  • mathemetical formulas in Latex between $ symbol

Question tags:

×232
×88
×82

question asked: 31 Mar '16, 16:06

question was seen: 1,666 times

last updated: 01 Jan '17, 18:43