COPR16A : Editorial

copr16
copr16a
easy
editorial
likecs

#1

PROBLEM LINK:

Practice

Contest

Author: Bhuvnesh Jain

Tester: Bhuvnesh Jain

Editorialist: Bhuvnesh Jain

DIFFICULTY:

EASY

PREREQUISITES:

Matrix Exponentiation, Modular Multiplication

PROBLEM:

Calculate the number of times fibonacci(k) is called in the recursive function given for fibonacci sequence.

EXPLANATION:

The solution is basically (n-k+1)^{th} Fibonacci number for k>=1.

The above can be proved by induction.

Proof By Induction (we will prove here for k \geq 1)

For n=0, there are no value of k possible, so the proposition is trivially true.

For n=1, we can only pick k=1. It is true that fibonacci(1) appears one time i.e. F_{1−1+1} = F_{1} = 1

Now we assume that our proposition is valid for all numbers smaller than n, (strong induction) and we’ll prove it for n. Let 1 \leq k \leq n. Let us draw the recursion tree for F_{n}, which we call T_{n}. If k = n, then clearly F_{n} only shows up 1 time in T_{n} i.e at the root of the recusion tree, so the result holds. Likewise, if k = (n−1), the only place we see F_{n−1} is as the root of our left subtree, the larger one. So the result holds in that case as well, since F_{n−(n−1)+1} = F_{2} = 1.

Let us then assume that k \leq (n-2), which allows us to use the inductive hypothesis on the left and right subtrees of T_{n}.

By induction, the number of times F_{k} appears in the left subtree is F_{n−1−k+1} = F_{n−k}, and the number of times it appears in the right subtree is F_{n−2−k+1} = F_{n−k−1}. Thus the number of times it appears in T_{n} is the sum of values at both the sub-trees, i.e. F_{n−k} \ + \ F_{n−k−1} = F_{n−k+1}, which was to be shown.

Hence By Principle of mathematical induction the result holds all n and k \geq 1.

But for k=0 the answer is (n-1)^{th} Fibonacci number. The corner case of k=0 can be seen from the recursion tree {T}_{n} drawn showing that it occurs the same number of time as k=2. So the formula is (n-2+1) = (n-1) as stated above.

To find the n^{th} fibonacci number, we can use Modular exponentiation which gives a complexity of O(log n).

But there is a more faster way to do this. You can refer to Codeforces blog for this. My solution uses the same concept but in a bit different and faster way.

Also, the test cases were weak as most of the solutions should have failed. As per the constraints, the modulo should be taken m where 1<=m<=10^{12}. As (10^{12}. 10^{12}) will overflow in C++, Java etc. without using big integer libraries, we needed to use Modular multiplication. One way to do this is using the same concept as modular multiplication and replacing the multipplication operations by additions. Below is the C++ function to do the same.

long long mulmod(long long a,long long b,long long c)
{
    long long x = 0,y=a%c;
    while(b '>' 0)
    {
        if(b%2 == 1)
        {
            x = (x+y)%c;
        }
        y = (y*2)%c;
        b /= 2;
    }
    return x%c;
}

You can also use a O(1) hack for the above as given in Praveen Dhinwa’s blog.

COMPLEXITY

O(${log}^2$n) or O(logn), depending on implementation of Modular multiplication function.

AUTHOR’S SOLUTION:

Author’s solution can be found here.


#2

Proof please :slight_smile:


#3

Proof added :slight_smile: